Mystery has had a larger band in the past but gave up half of them in 2012. Like Sidekick, Mystery seems to have a preference for certain colors of mares, having kept the darker mares and given up the brighter colored mares. The dark mares have remained loyal to him for several years, but he lost his young Papoose to Blaze the summer of 2014. In 2015 Mystery picked up Cedar and later Sundance, from Red Face's band. Both mares are bay. He also took Ember's Girl from Thundercloud, who had gotten her from Copper when Copper was badly injured in 2014. His is one of the bands that is often found close to other bands in the area of Talkington Trail, Boicourt, and Lindbo Flats.